As a firm believer of inbound marketing, I spend a good chunk of my time in research and experiments. This is the key to building an effective strategy that keeps scaling.
Aside from inbound (given a HubSpot agency partner), we work with multiple publishers delivering 20M – 150M monthly page views through programmatic advertisement. The healthy mix of inbound and outbound allows us to gauge the efficiency of our campaigns and mix in some PR and brand positioning for DevriX and our long-term partners.
And since marketing strategies are among the trickiest business challenges out there, here’s a practical example revealing the effectiveness of each component in the mix.
Should I Ignore The Marketing Mix at First?
Of course not!
Relying on a single channel to grow a business is risky. Especially with inbound marketing: it’s a long-term play. An extremely powerful one, but long-term.
You keep scaling slowly and it’s immensely powerful once you get some traction.
Whenever you are looking for some initial traction, including some PPC in your marketing strategy will be paramount for success. Here’s why inbound alone doesn’t fit each and every use case.
The Inbound Marketing Teardown
Imagine managing a library.
You own a wonderful building in a less populated area equipped with the whole book collection since Babylon.
The book collection is useful to a large audience of users: students, teachers, hobbyists, fantasy fans, historians, journalists — you name it.
How to attract more recurring visitors to your library?
Inbound vs. Outbound Marketing
You have two possible promotional approaches:
- Inbound: add more and more content, organize your libraries by categories, hire greeting staff who will welcome and smile all day, navigating potential visitors to the right area, place some directional labels at the front door.
- Outbound: call each and every newspaper in town, promote your library there, contact all universities and give talks on-site, buy ads in radio and TV stations.
Which approach would generate actual user base to your library?
Inbound marketing is a fairly new approach that hasn’t proven itself to each and every vertical out there. Granted, it works and it is a splendid strategy in the long run. But traditional businesses and old-school management firmly believe in results.
Outbound has been around for a century since tobacco advertisement has been introduced in 1920.
- When you buy a page in a newsletter, you know how many copies would be distributed in each issue.
- If you purchase some ads on a site, you negotiate the monthly page views and can (eventually) track incoming visits for each ad.
- Hiring an outbound sales revolves around quotas – a number of calls or emails a day and expected conversion rates.
A Marketing Strategy Plan Example
The problem with inbound marketing is tied to expectations and dreams. It’s a wonderful approach that is far more viable and rewarding in the long run, but smaller and mid-sized businesses may not be around when results start to kick in.
Moreover, plenty of inbound marketers can’t implement the best practices for certain niches. The fact that you can write good copy and create a landing page doesn’t necessarily mean that visitors will relate to your story and convert to leads and customers. It requires deeper understanding of the business needs and pain points and a good funnel that also requires PPC for proper A/B testing.
Here’s a standard marketing funnel chart that defines the high-end overview of the marketing process:
Essentially, you have three main points of the online sales cycle:
- Traffic – the amount of incoming visitors through organic search, referrals, social media, direct links, press releases etc.
- Conversion rates – the visitor-to-customer ratio, or what percentage of visitors actually convert to leads or customers.
- Product cost – the nominal cost of a product.
For example, if you receive 5000 views a month and 10 of them become customers of a $50 product, this means $500 in revenue and 0.2% conversion rate.
You can increase your revenue by growing your traffic volume, improving your landing page offering for higher conversions, or increase your product cost as long as it doesn’t drop your conversions too much.
Outbound marketing may take care of the traffic aspect. Double the traffic and you’ll end up with $1,000 a month. Quadruple it and it will be $2K monthly. This makes sense if your ad spending costs less than your CAC (customer acquisition cost).
What Would An Inbound Marketer Do?
- Plan for writing a hundred more articles that would supposedly rank and get viral
- Design an ebook or a free educational email course
- Create more landing pages for different verticals
- Try to outsmart Google with its ranking algorithm
- Share ingenious statuses on social media
Sure, all of the above may work out in a year from now after paying a $5K – $20K monthly retainer. There’s a chance that one of the story gets viral as well – on reddit, StumbleUpon, linked within Quora answers or somewhere else.
Tracking Results For a Marketing Strategy Plan
Tracking success with inbound marketing is more challenging than outbound. There are KPIs that professional marketers can track nowadays and try to adjust their campaigns in order to maximize their results and minimize costs. Most of them require a professional platform like HubSpot and an experienced team that could sift through data and build a professional strategy around it.
But it may be an expensive endeavor for a small business in a competitive space with a target market of people who don’t live online.
We also offer inbound marketing services but often decline RFPs from businesses that won’t benefit from our services.
- A study from 2014 outlined that businesses spend an average of 10% of their revenue on all forms of marketing. Numbers may vary and giants like Twitter and Salesforce spend over 40% a year accordingly – but that’s far from the norm.
- A small business generating $100K a year can only afford $10K annually on marketing. This is roughly a $800/mo retainer for a marketer that should increase the revenue and justify the marketing investment. After all, it’s all about ROI.
- An average freelance hourly marketing rate is between $50 and $100 per hour. Even if we pick the lowest rate, that’s 16 hours a month in marketing work or two full-time days.
I’ve explained all of this in a comparison video discussing hiring, outsourcing to a freelancer or partnering up with an agency here:
How much content work, landing page development, email automation, outreach, SEO or social media work could a professional handle within two business days a month?
How long would it take until that content picks traction and generates a steady and consistent traffic growth – even if it targets the right marketing venues given the predefined buyer personas (unless the marketer has to navigate and organize the entire marketing strategy from scratch and coordinate a possible redesign)?
Now compare it to the average number of calls per day being 150–300 cold calls daily, or 300–600 monthly calls within the quota, or the seemingly sure “Cost per click” model in paid advertisement.
A no-brainer, correct?
Inbound Marketing Isn’t What You Think
Now, the main mistake people do when comparing inbound vs. outbound is the perception that inbound is “mainly content development”.
Here’s why this perception is flawed. Let’s review the breakdown of inbound marketing and its nemesis, the “interruption marketing”:
Inbound marketing starts with content production. Then it branches down into:
- Public relations
- Influencer outreach
- Community building
- Thought leadership and executive branding
- Repurposing to video or audio
- Word of mouth and referral marketing
- Credibility through reviews, case studies, testimonials
The main difference between both “schools of marketing” is intent. With outbound, you strive to intercept the attention of your audience. Inbound brings leads straight to you in a non-intrusive manner.
PPC And The Risk With Outbound Marketing
We work with well over a dozen publishers on a monthly basis. Some focus entirely on organic while others serve hundreds of millions of views brought in by paid advertising.
It was all rainbows and unicorns until a few months back when Facebook started struggling big time around all privacy and data leak scandals throughout the past year. Policies were updated a dozen times. New regulations kicked in and changed the rules of the game entirely.
Some publishers invested 7 figures a month in Facebook advertisement, and had a really, really rough Q4. We went above and beyond to revamp a good chunk of their sites and layouts, build additional integrations with alternatives, hook up with Snapchat for traffic and anything we could to keep them afloat.
Our organic publishers completely missed all the drama — plus the ones that advertise got some extra boost during the holidays seasons.
Risking your business model entirely on a 3rd party business or a marketplace is usually a recipe for disaster. Diversifying revenue opportunities is a safe bet, and generating revenue through your website by reducing the dependency on a fluid cost model is a lot smarter than fully immersing into a paid advertisement (or sales) model.
I’m a firm believer in inbound marketing, being a certified Inbound Marketer who is lucky to work with successful business that can benefit from minor strategic adjustments that generate 5 figures in additional sales per month thanks to a viral piece of content or a genuine landing page.
But this — this requires an established brand,
What channel has generated the most significant ROI for your business? Share your success story in the comments below.